Health Care – The Magic Drawer Full of Money is Your Pocket
Editor’s note: Great post on the Coyote Blog. If you have been following this blog, the punchline below is something you have heard early and often…
Greg Mankiw writes about a Paul Krugman article on “the public option,” a plan in Congress to provide a federal health insurance plan to compete with private plans and “keep them honest”**
It seems to me that [Krugman] leaves out the answer to the key question: Would the public plan have access to taxpayer funds unavailable to private plans?
If the answer is yes, then the public plan would not offer honest competition to private plans. The taxpayer subsidies would tilt the playing field in favor of the public plan. In this case, the whole idea of a public option seems to be a disingenuous route toward a single-payer system, which many on the left favor but recognize is a political nonstarter.
If the answer is no, then the public plan would need to stand on its own financially and, in essence, would be a private nonprofit plan. But then what’s the point? If advocates of a public plan want to start a nonprofit company offering health insurance on better terms than existing insurance companies, nothing is stopping them from doing so right now. There is free entry into the market for health insurance. If a public plan without taxpayer support would succeed, so would a nonprofit insurance company. The fundamental viability of the enterprise does not depend on whether the employees are called “nonprofit administrators” or “civil servants.” (via Q&O)
But I think we already know the answer to this question. If Obama and the Democratic Congress is willing to pour a hundred billion dollars or more down the Chrysler and GM rat holes, they certainly are going to pony up far more to support a program so near and dear to their heart for so many years.
There is simply not some magic, easy to access pool of savings in health care available to government managers that will reduce costs 30% or pay for increases in benefits. If there were, Medicare should have already captured them.
** This is always hilarious to see, as if health insurers make some kind of inordinate profits. As shown before, the typical after-tax profit at health care companies and insurers is something like 3-4% of revenues.
No comments yet.